Question:
That’s been my experience at the brewshop, liquid is cheaper. I’ve been brewing mixes of liquid and dry lately too. The DME seems gives a slightly lighter brew, at least with the particular pale ale extracts I’ve been using. That seems to be one reason for mixing them in the brewshops kits pay a little more to lighten it up. I guess it could also be that the lighter the brew the more important consistency of quality in the extract, but my observation is that the DME gives a lighter brew. I could be totally wrong here but it’s what I’ve observed with the local ingredients and recipes. Personally, I think the liquid is a little "grainier" smelling and tasting too, I actually like the liquid results a little better, but that’s my taste and again the local shop’s particular ingredients. Ebb
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – DME is lighter, but I’ve never used it to brew… so I dont know the quality vs. liquid malt extract. Quality is better IMO. How old is the LME is always a question, and the age can affect the beer. DME is dried. In a closed container, it should last a very long time without changing characteristics. Why’s LME so much more popular then? I’ve seen plenty of variety of DME, so it cant be that. Cost is a factor. Forgetting about bulk quantities and shipping for a moment LME is about $2 a pound and DME is about $3 a pound. Factoring in 20% water in LME, it’s still cheaper. Medford, NY swap net.optonline to reply via e-mail
Response:
My system I made from a $14 40qt cooler at Walmart, and $5 in CPVC tubing parts fitted together in some funky pattern, and drilled full of holes as manifold. I did a 45% wheat 55% barley mash a few weeks ago, and although I’ve heard the horrors of wheat mashing and stuck sparges, had no problem whatsoever. Some pics of it, and other brewing junk I’ve made are at http://www.ebonmists.com/brewing
I noticed from your pics that when you have your manifold installed in your mash tun, the holes are on the top. I’m assuming that you have holes drilled only on one side and are fly sparging? In this arrangement, you are probably not leaching sugars out of any grain that sits below the level of the holes, IE the 1" of grain on the bottom which is around the manifold. It may not make a huge difference, but you might be able to improve your efficiency some by flipping the manifold over so that the holes are on the bottom. John. — *** John P. Kolesar *** *** Valley Mead Brewery ***
Response:
Why’s LME so much more popular then? I’ve seen plenty of variety of DME, so it cant be that. That’s a very good question. I don’t know, but maybe it has something to do with LME being easier to make than DME, so there is more of a supply? That’s just a guess.
At a wholesale level, at least, DME is 60% more expensive than LME on a dollars per gravity point basis. That is a big difference. — Dan Listermann Check out our E-tail site at www.listermann.com Free shipping for orders greater than $35 and East of the Mighty Miss. " – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – John. — *** John P. Kolesar *** *** Valley Mead Brewery ***
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – DME is lighter, but I’ve never used it to brew… so I dont know the quality vs. liquid malt extract. Quality is better IMO. How old is the LME is always a question, and the age can affect the beer. DME is dried. In a closed container, it should last a very long time without changing characteristics. Why’s LME so much more popular then? I’ve seen plenty of variety of DME, so it cant be that.
That’s a very good question. I don’t know, but maybe it has something to do with LME being easier to make than DME, so there is more of a supply? That’s just a guess. John. — *** John P. Kolesar *** *** Valley Mead Brewery ***
Response:
Thanks for the tips. I’ll have to get more serious about building an AG setup. Mainly I have been seeing cost in the equipment to heat and cool. An immersion chiller seems easiest, but you’ve got to buy copper tubing, not too excessively expensive I guess, especially when considering what I already have invested in my equipment. A propane burner seems almost necessary, my natural gas stove is a little slow. I have a nice 5 gallon brew pot, but I assume I’ll need at least a 7 gallon, so there’s some money there too – I have seen the converted kegs for this purpose that could save some there. The insulated containers for mashing and buckets and plumbing for lautering etc should be pretty cheap. In all, I don’t see it costing more than what I’ve already spent, but still it adds up to a few bucks. I’ll definitely get there and I appreciate any input on construction. I’ve got welding equipment and skills so that should help. The other thing holding me off is I want to get a kegerator going, I mean maintaining 10 cases of bottles aging different stuff and turning over a few cases per month is really getting to be a chore. So AG may have to be put on the back burner, no pun intended. Thanks, ebb
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I’ve been brewing about 2 or 3 5-gallon batches per month now for awhile. I haven’t yet gathered enough $$ to start assembling good all-grain equipment and I’m happy with my results with extracts. I am tired of buying ingredients for 2 or 3 batches at a time. Most of the stuff I brew takes pale ale malt syrup and various steeping grains. I’d like to just buy a bucket of syrup, a variety of grains, hops and yeast. I’d also like to start reusing yeast, recovering it and keeping it in the refrigerator. Here’s the question part. Where’s a good place to order, say a 5 gallon bucket or so of liquid pale malt extract. What brand/type would be recommended as general staple for a variety of brews? Thanks, ebb
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – DME is lighter, but I’ve never used it to brew… so I dont know the quality vs. liquid malt extract. Quality is better IMO. How old is the LME is always a question, and the age can affect the beer. DME is dried. In a closed container, it should last a very long time without changing characteristics. Why’s LME so much more popular then? I’ve seen plenty of variety of DME, so it cant be that.
I’m not convinced it is more popular. Most of the avid extract brewers I know use DME and grains. New brewers tend to purchase kits that are LME based. I would think it wouldn’t take as much labor to make LME as DME. I started with LME, but ended up my extract carrer using blends of both to try and tweak beers… Cheers, Mike
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – DME is lighter, but I’ve never used it to brew… so I dont know the quality vs. liquid malt extract. Quality is better IMO. How old is the LME is always a question, and the age can affect the beer. DME is dried. In a closed container, it should last a very long time without changing characteristics. Why’s LME so much more popular then? I’ve seen plenty of variety of DME, so it cant be that.
Cost is a factor. Forgetting about bulk quantities and shipping for a moment LME is about $2 a pound and DME is about $3 a pound. Factoring in 20% water in LME, it’s still cheaper. Medford, NY swap net.optonline to reply via e-mail
Response:
On the all-grain equipment thing, I’ve recently discovered the following item on Dan Listermann’s site. http://www.listermann.com/Store/Details.asp?ID=338 It says "All-grain brewing made easy with inexpensive, efficient, complete system. Includes hot liquor bucket, sparging arm, sparge bucket, false bottom and all hoses." for $44.95. I’m seriously considering going for this myself. So far, I’ve only been making extract (with specialty grain) batches, and I’m looking forward to moving on to the "next step."
I believe that setup just uses a regular ‘beer bucket’ to mash in. Get some of that blue insulating foam from home depot or lowes or whatnot to insulate it, else you’ll lose a lot of heat. My system I made from a $14 40qt cooler at Walmart, and $5 in CPVC tubing parts fitted together in some funky pattern, and drilled full of holes as manifold. I did a 45% wheat 55% barley mash a few weeks ago, and although I’ve heard the horrors of wheat mashing and stuck sparges, had no problem whatsoever. Some pics of it, and other brewing junk I’ve made are at http://www.ebonmists.com/brewing
Response:
DME is lighter, but I’ve never used it to brew… so I dont know the quality vs. liquid malt extract. Quality is better IMO. How old is the LME is always a question, and the age can affect the beer. DME is dried. In a closed container, it should last a very long time without changing characteristics.
Why’s LME so much more popular then? I’ve seen plenty of variety of DME, so it cant be that.
Response:
On the all-grain equipment thing, I’ve recently discovered the following item on Dan Listermann’s site. http://www.listermann.com/Store/Details.asp?ID=338 It says "All-grain brewing made easy with inexpensive, efficient, complete system. Includes hot liquor bucket, sparging arm, sparge bucket, false bottom and all hoses." for $44.95. I’m seriously considering going for this myself. So far, I’ve only been making extract (with specialty grain) batches, and I’m looking forward to moving on to the "next step."
Not that Dan shouldn’t make any money, but an AG setup can be made for practically nothing, see my page…. Cheers, Mike www.ipass.net/~mpdixon/homebrew.htm
Response:
On the all-grain equipment thing, I’ve recently discovered the following item on Dan Listermann’s site. http://www.listermann.com/Store/Details.asp?ID=338 It says "All-grain brewing made easy with inexpensive, efficient, complete system. Includes hot liquor bucket, sparging arm, sparge bucket, false bottom and all hoses." for $44.95. I’m seriously considering going for this myself. So far, I’ve only been making extract (with specialty grain) batches, and I’m looking forward to moving on to the "next step." — Lafe Homepage: http://www.lafes.net/ Forums: http://forums.lafes.net/ Beer Forum: http://forums.lafes.net/index.php?act=SF&f=3
Response:
DME is lighter, but I’ve never used it to brew… so I dont know the quality vs. liquid malt extract.
Quality is better IMO. How old is the LME is always a question, and the age can affect the beer. DME is dried. In a closed container, it should last a very long time without changing characteristics. Cheers, Mike
Response:
I’ve been brewing about 2 or 3 5-gallon batches per month now for awhile. I haven’t yet gathered enough $$ to start assembling good all-grain equipment and I’m happy with my results with extracts. I am tired of buying ingredients for 2 or 3 batches at a time. Most of the stuff I brew takes pale ale malt syrup and various steeping grains. I’d like to just buy a bucket of syrup, a variety of grains, hops and yeast. I’d also like to start reusing yeast, recovering it and keeping it in the refrigerator. Here’s the question part. Where’s a good place to order, say a 5 gallon bucket or so of liquid pale malt extract. What brand/type would be recommended as general staple for a variety of brews?
Many homebrew places on the web would be happy to ship you whatever you want. Try and order from someplace closeby, that will charge you actual UPS cost, and have it sent to your work address (UPS ships to commerical addresses for cheaper than residential). I had a 45 pound wine kit sent to me at work for $8.50. I paid that much to have a 1 pound regulator shipped halfway cross country. DME is lighter, but I’ve never used it to brew… so I dont know the quality vs. liquid malt extract.
Response:
I’ve been brewing about 2 or 3 5-gallon batches per month now for awhile. I haven’t yet gathered enough $$ to start assembling good all-grain
equipment See my page for some ideas on how to start out on the cheap…. www.ipass.net/~mpdixon/homebrew.htm and I’m happy with my results with extracts. I am tired of buying ingredients for 2 or 3 batches at a time. Most of the stuff I brew takes pale ale malt syrup and various steeping grains. I’d like to just buy a bucket of syrup, a variety of grains, hops and yeast. I’d also like to start reusing yeast, recovering it and keeping it in the refrigerator. Here’s the question part. Where’s a good place to order, say a 5 gallon bucket or so of liquid pale malt extract. What brand/type would be recommended as general staple for a variety of brews?
I’d suggest looking into DME and save the cost of shipping. In LME, you are shipping water weight… Cheers, Mike
Response:
Here’s the question part. Where’s a good place to order, say a 5 gallon bucket or so of liquid pale malt extract?
Get it somewhere close! It weighs a lot and shipping is high. Many LHBS’s buy it by the 55 gallon drum and will let you bring in a 5 gallon pail and fill it. They sell it by the pound. Between uses, pour some vodka on the surface to prevent mold. Burp, -Dan — Replace nospam with msn to email me.
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I’ve been brewing about 2 or 3 5-gallon batches per month now for awhile. I haven’t yet gathered enough $$ to start assembling good all-grain equipment and I’m happy with my results with extracts. I am tired of buying ingredients for 2 or 3 batches at a time. Most of the stuff I brew takes pale ale malt syrup and various steeping grains. I’d like to just buy a bucket of syrup, a variety of grains, hops and yeast. I’d also like to start reusing yeast, recovering it and keeping it in the refrigerator. Here’s the question part. Where’s a good place to order, say a 5 gallon bucket or so of liquid pale malt extract. What brand/type would be recommended as general staple for a variety of brews? Thanks, ebb
Response:
I’ve been brewing about 2 or 3 5-gallon batches per month now for awhile. I haven’t yet gathered enough $$ to start assembling good all-grain equipment and I’m happy with my results with extracts. I am tired of buying ingredients for 2 or 3 batches at a time. Most of the stuff I brew takes pale ale malt syrup and various steeping grains. I’d like to just buy a bucket of syrup, a variety of grains, hops and yeast. I’d also like to start reusing yeast, recovering it and keeping it in the refrigerator. Here’s the question part. Where’s a good place to order, say a 5 gallon bucket or so of liquid pale malt extract. What brand/type would be recommended as general staple for a variety of brews? Thanks, ebb
Response: