Question:
says… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I’d like to get input on aging beer in a wood cask or barrel? Is this done in Europe but not in the US? What about homebrewing? What’s needed to do it? What size casks or barrels are used and which wood: Oak or chestnut? Thanks, Largo Fermenting in wood would result in all sorts of problems with infection. Fermenting in wood lined with pitch would be no different than fermenting in plastic (or any other material) lined with pitch. It’s really not worth the trouble, unless you’re dealing with the small subset of styles in which a controlled infection is ok. If you want a wood flavor, add some wood chips or cubes (which are easy to Does the same hold true for secondary fermentation? Do a primary fermentation in glass, then the secondary in wood. I would think the higher alcohol content would make infection less likely. Similar to making wine, you age in barrels, not ferment in barrels. There is a brewery in Berkeley called Triple Rock, they usually have 2 cask conditioned beer on tap. You can even taste the cask conditioned side by side with the kegged beer. I’ll have to ask them next time I’m there how they sanitize their casks.
Are you sure they use wooden casks? Most pubs in the Bay Area serve cask conditioned ales, but wooden casks are typically not used.
Response:
There is a brewery in Berkeley called Triple Rock, they usually have 2 cask conditioned beer on tap. You can even taste the cask conditioned side by side with the kegged beer. I’ll have to ask them next time I’m there how they sanitize their casks.
Commercial casks are stainless steel. Historically, they were wood, but modern casks are not. Cask conditioning refers to a process of serving the beer from a fermentation vessel. Casks are sealed with spiles (wood, but never in contact with the beer) that allow for a limited venting of gases during secondary (or teritary) fermentation. A cask conditioned beer will taste quite different than a kegged beer, but not because of contact with wood. Besides the smaller amount of carbination, there is a different flavor probably from the small amount of oxidation through the wood.
Because of the pressure within the cask and the fact that fermentation is still occuring when the cask is placed in its serving position there is no oxidation of a cask conditioned ale until it is served. Once the cask is opened and beer is drawn off, air gets drawn into the vessel (if it is served without a CO2 rebreather) and oxidation occurs. This does not have a noticable effect until a couple days go by (at which point, many people consider it to be at its peak). After a few more days the oxidation becomes deleterious to the beer flavor. Trevor
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I’d like to get input on aging beer in a wood cask or barrel? Is this done in Europe but not in the US? What about homebrewing? What’s needed to do it? What size casks or barrels are used and which wood: Oak or chestnut? Thanks, Largo Fermenting in wood would result in all sorts of problems with infection. Fermenting in wood lined with pitch would be no different than fermenting in plastic (or any other material) lined with pitch. It’s really not worth the trouble, unless you’re dealing with the small subset of styles in which a controlled infection is ok. If you want a wood flavor, add some wood chips or cubes (which are easy to
Does the same hold true for secondary fermentation? Do a primary fermentation in glass, then the secondary in wood. I would think the higher alcohol content would make infection less likely. Similar to making wine, you age in barrels, not ferment in barrels. There is a brewery in Berkeley called Triple Rock, they usually have 2 cask conditioned beer on tap. You can even taste the cask conditioned side by side with the kegged beer. I’ll have to ask them next time I’m there how they sanitize their casks. There is definitely a different texture to cask conditioned beers that goes beyond what wood ships will do for you. Besides the smaller amount of carbination, there is a different flavor probably from the small amount of oxidation through the wood. Just my thoughts, not an expert. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – sanitize) to the fermenter, and if you want a cask-like serving vessel, get a firkin or something similar. -Kevin
Response:
I’d like to get input on aging beer in a wood cask or barrel? Is this done in Europe but not in the US? What about homebrewing? What’s needed to do it? What size casks or barrels are used and which wood: Oak or chestnut? Thanks, Largo
Fermenting in wood would result in all sorts of problems with infection. Fermenting in wood lined with pitch would be no different than fermenting in plastic (or any other material) lined with pitch. It’s really not worth the trouble, unless you’re dealing with the small subset of styles in which a controlled infection is ok. If you want a wood flavor, add some wood chips or cubes (which are easy to sanitize) to the fermenter, and if you want a cask-like serving vessel, get a firkin or something similar. -Kevin
Response:
I’d like to get input on aging beer in a wood cask or barrel? Is this done in Europe but not in the US? What about homebrewing? What’s needed to do it? What size casks or barrels are used and which wood: Oak or chestnut? Thanks, Largo
Response:
A very involved question. I suppose that the use of wooden casks began because there was nothing else that would do at the time.I well remember the time when almost all beer was transported in wood. The casks would be rolled and even bounced into the cellars.You can’t bounce a stainless steel cask like that ! The preferred medium is oak. I am not sure why – maybe availability or because of the physical charecteristic of the wood. It takes a very skilled craftsman to make a watertight container out of wood. I understand the inside was coated with pitch .There are still a couple of UK brewers using oak casks and one brewer is still producing them. Different sizes had different names. A 36 (UK) gallon cask was a barrel. An 18 gallon was an anker A 9 gallon was a firkin A 4 1/2 gallon was a pin. Also there were larger sizes but the names and capacities might have regional differences ; Holt’s of Manchester still uses hogsheads of 54 UK gallons and a puncheon was 72 gallons. The modern tendency is to use smaller casks for ease of handling and storage. Also in the old days a pub might only sell 2 brews and use barrels but nowadays sells a large range of ales from firkins. Some people swear by the use of wood , that it gives a superior product.Sam Smiths offer their Old Brewery Bitter in both wood and metal casks.But there are problems in hygeine and the risk of off tastes.And they are heavy brutes. A barrel of beer must weigh around a quarter of a ton.
Response:
Thanks for your input. I think you’re correct–sanitation may be difficult with a material like wood with tar pitch. Glass carboys are ideal, easy to clean and maintain. I ask since seeing oak casks at http://www.brouwland.com under demijohns. Maybe they’re for wine making. Largo – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -A very involved question. I suppose that the use of wooden casks began because there was nothing else that would do at the time.I well remember the time when almost all beer was transported in wood. The casks would be rolled and even bounced into the cellars.You can’t bounce a stainless steel cask like that ! The preferred medium is oak. I am not sure why – maybe availability or because of the physical charecteristic of the wood. It takes a very skilled craftsman to make a watertight container out of wood. I understand the inside was coated with pitch .There are still a couple of UK brewers using oak casks and one brewer is still producing them. Different sizes had different names. A 36 (UK) gallon cask was a barrel. An 18 gallon was an anker A 9 gallon was a firkin A 4 1/2 gallon was a pin. Also there were larger sizes but the names and capacities might have regional differences ; Holt’s of Manchester still uses hogsheads of 54 UK gallons and a puncheon was 72 gallons. The modern tendency is to use smaller casks for ease of handling and storage. Also in the old days a pub might only sell 2 brews and use barrels but nowadays sells a large range of ales from firkins. Some people swear by the use of wood , that it gives a superior product.Sam Smiths offer their Old Brewery Bitter in both wood and metal casks.But there are problems in hygeine and the risk of off tastes.And they are heavy brutes. A barrel of beer must weigh around a quarter of a ton.
Posted in